Diskusi Fotografi > Medium dan Large Format
leica s2 vs phase one

Abimanyu Asvaintra
26 April 2010 10:48:34 WIB

0 0 52  Dilihat : 6543

lagi2 leica release dslr styled body dengan sensor medium format dengan harga selangit. kan technology digital selalu jadi obsolete, lalu gimana kalau mau upgrade jeroan body s2? sedangkan kalau beli hasselblad atau mamiya body masih bisa kita keep, tinggal upgrade back phase one saja, jangan2 nanti kayak R system lagi!

Leica, knapa nggak buat M system aja sih, M system full format gedein sedikit bodynya M tapi masih bisa pakai M lenses dari pada start dari scratch dengan body S2 yang gedenya segede kepala orang, berat, non auto focus, technology berkembang ke gadgets yang lebih kecil ringan dll biar bisa lebih portable seperti M9 system(fyi, professionals udah nge ditch D3x, 1d series yang segede bagong ke m9 full format yang lebih portable makaynya m9 sold out dimana2 soalnya di garap sama professionals), pengen liat s2 sampai kapan existnya.

your thoughts?

 

 

 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Abimanyu Asvaintra 26 April 2010 10:54:55 WIB
This sort of makes the LEICA S2 irrelevant. The LEICA S2 has no RealRaw capability, limited resolution (not even 40MP), a horribly outdated amateur 3:2 aspect ratio, and a small sensor barely bigger than 35mm.

The S2's sensor is only 30 x 45mm, not 40.4 x 53.9mm like the Phase One P65+ sensor. The widest lens for the S2 is the 35mm, while the Contax 645 system offers a 35mm lens. A 35mm lens on Leica's smaller S2 sensor is equivalent only to a 45mm lens on the Contax 645.

The Contax 645 system offers an exotic Zeiss 350mm f/4; the longest for the S2 is only 180mm today.

The Contax 645 system sells for much less and is much easier to find than the S2 system. The S2 is new, expensive and not in stock. You can get anything you want for the Contax 645 used at this link to it at eBay, and most of it is still like new. If you're new to the Contax 645, you can find plenty of used kits with the body, finder, back, film insert, 80/2 lens and etc for about $1,400 still in their boxes, complete and ready to shoot. A beater kit with the 80mm will sell for about $999, at least over eBay. The 45mm and 140mm lenses usually go for about $650 each, bargains for autofocus Zeiss lenses.

The Contax 645 system is modular. When the Phase One digital back goes obsolete, throw it out and shoot RealRaw, or get the newest back.

The LEICA S2 is not modular. The prism, shutter body and digital sensor are all one piece. When the S2 gets digital rot, the entire S2 camera has to be thrown out just like any other DSLR. These sections are all modular on the Contax 645; if a back goes obsolete, just replace it.

The LEICA S2 lenses sell for $5,300 - $7,500 each. Contax 645 lenses sell (used) for a few hundred dollars (the 80mm f/2) to no more than $5,500 for the exotic Zeiss 350mm f/4. The S2's 35mm lens will set you back $6,000 if it ever ships, while you can get the Zeiss 35mm for the Contax for around $1,500.

Are the Leica lenses better than Zeiss, giving the S2 the same advantage the 18MP M9 has over 24MP DSLRs? I doubt it. My tests of other Leica-vs-Zeiss lenses for the same application has proven the Zeiss to be as good or better optically than Leica for a lot less money. (Rangefinder and 4x5 lenses are better than SLR lenses, but that's another day's story.)

I'll stick with an M9 over the S2. Of course when I get to play with an S2 I'll probably have a different opinion. Then again, I see no aperture ring on the S2. How am I supposed to shoot if I have to hold a button to change the aperture? That would not be LEICA. I see no shooting mode or aperture dials on the S2; the Contax 645 has dedicated controls for everything. The S2 lacks depth-of-field scales; the Contax 645 has them for precise control.
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Wirasandi Ruslan 26 April 2010 11:32:02 WIB
mendingan motret ajah..apapun kameranya.. whistling
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Danang Bimo Irianto 26 April 2010 11:34:22 WIB
here we go again....www.nulisgrafer.net
" moto teruss....pake keyboard..."

0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Angga Baskara 26 April 2010 11:38:03 WIB
superlative big grin
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Wirasandi Ruslan 26 April 2010 11:40:47 WIB
btw.. itu tulisan review yang nginggris pengalaman TS sendiri yah? wuihh..!

hebaaaaat.. punya S2, M9, Contax.. applause


oiya lupa.. sama lensa superlative daydreaming - New!
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Sarwo Edie Setijono 26 April 2010 11:44:42 WIB
Klw yang ini harus nunggu berapa taon belinya.... whistling
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Yudanto Ramadon 26 April 2010 11:48:41 WIB
@DBI : rolling on the floor

@ TS : Ini pengalaman pribadi?
bisa dikasih contoh foto masing-masing.. untuk perbandingan?
Hasil fotonya yah.. bukan foto kameranya..
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Syarif Hidayat 26 April 2010 12:04:52 WIB
Ulasan yang superlative whistling
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Nixon Glenn 26 April 2010 12:11:22 WIB
ONE WORD: SUPERLATIVE!
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Erik Estrada 26 April 2010 13:01:57 WIB
daydreaming - New!
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Nur Alam MN 26 April 2010 13:04:05 WIB
@dbi : wewewedotnulisgraferdotkom laughinglaughinglaughinglaughing
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Pujo C Agustiyanto 26 April 2010 13:11:10 WIB
btw tertarik kalo ada contohnya dong....

professional yang mana yang ninggalin d3x? mereka pindah ke D3s kali yah? kalo iyah mau dong dikasih bekasnya

btw itu leica dan lensa teman2nya bukannya kamera untuk orang berduit yah?

kalo 80% proffesional di sport dan jurnalistik mungkin mikir-mikir pake systemnya leica. soalnya kalo dah waktunya ganti saynag di buang sedangkan kalo pake merek jepang kalo udah tua lebih nggak miris kalo mau di singkirkan.
andaikata punya duit???~~~~
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Chaerul Umam 26 April 2010 13:22:42 WIB
bakal dihapus lagi ndak yah thread ini daydreaming - New!
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Yudanto Ramadon 26 April 2010 13:38:11 WIB
@ TS : mana hasil foto dari S2 dan Phase One?
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Meylan Fredy Ismawan 26 April 2010 13:56:37 WIB
kalau beli lensa superlative aja nunggunya 18 tahun, saya yakin Anda butuh 1 milenium kalau beli Leica & Phase One .... hee hee
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Yunas Sasangka 26 April 2010 14:13:36 WIB
bakalan seru nih topik.. hee hee
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Aditya Arad Wicaksono,DoF 26 April 2010 15:17:32 WIB
Camera Superlative....sejak berapa tahun yang lalukah nunggu Leica S2 ini..? tongue
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Lay Kana 26 April 2010 15:58:42 WIB
copy paste.......
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Bayu Sakti 26 April 2010 16:00:01 WIB
....body S2 yang gedenya segede kepala orang, berat, non auto focus, technology berkembang ke gadgets yang lebih kecil ringan dll...

dimension : 160 x 120 x 81 mm (6.3 x 4.7 x 3.2 in)
The autofocus developed by Leica for the S2 is based on a centrally positioned cross-hair sensor for high precision focusing. Each S lens has its own Leica-designed microprocessor for precise autofocus and iris diaphragm control. The integrated focusing drive is a proprietary Leica design that features silent gearing. All S lenses have a generous focus ring with just the right amount of drag, letting the photographer override the autofocus at any time.
0 0 
 
Re: leica s2 vs phase one
Bayu Sakti 26 April 2010 16:10:58 WIB
big grin big grin big grin big grin
repot juga..
bawa kamera kecil..dibilang "kamera kok ndak serius bla bla bla.."
teknologi ndak di upgrade..dibilang ketinggalan jaman.

0 0